Hybrid proctoring: when and how to combine AI with human review

by

A hybrid proctoring system combines the strengths of AI and human judgment to ensure exam integrity that is scalable, privacy-conscious, and grounded in fairness.

TL;DR

Hybrid online proctoring merges AI monitoring with human review to help organizations expand testing securely and fairly. AI detects and flags potential issues; trained proctors provide context and act when needed. It is a balanced approach for accessible and trustworthy remote exams.

Intro

Remote assessment has become a standard practice in higher education, certification programs, and corporate training. In fact, research published by EDUCAUSE in 2021, based on an analysis of over 2,000 North American college and university websites, found that around 63% use some form of proctoring software. Beyond fully automated AI monitoring, many organizations also rely on live human proctoring.

AI-assisted exam supervision makes it easier to monitor multiple exams at once. Live proctoring adds human context and fast judgment. Yet each model has limitations. AI can misinterpret normal behavior as suspicious, but human proctors aren’t flawless either. They can make subjective judgments or even respond unfairly. Also, full human supervision can be expensive and difficult to scale. That’s where hybrid proctoring (the combination of AI and human review) comes in.

In this article, we describe when and how to use hybrid proctoring effectively, and how this blended approach can make online exams more secure, fair, and efficient.

What is AI proctoring?

AI proctoring uses automated exam monitoring tools to protect exam integrity without requiring a human observer. Advanced algorithms analyze video, audio, identity verification, and screen activity to detect unusual behaviors, such as multiple faces on camera, frequent focus shifts, or screen anomalies.

Even though AI can identify unusual patterns on its own, every exam is slightly different. Schools and organizations can adjust the monitoring rules and sensitivity to match the exam type, whether quick quizzes, midterms, or high-stakes professional certification tests. That flexibility supports fair testing and scalable proctoring for large cohorts or multiple sessions.

OctoProctor’s AI proctoring platform builds on these capabilities. It operates in the browser with no downloads required and meets privacy standards in the US, EU, and other regions. We support thousands of simultaneous tests while sending real-time cheating detection alerts.

We also provide configurable settings and seamless integration with existing learning management systems, making AI-assisted exam supervision practical to deploy.

What is live proctoring?

Live proctoring provides real-time supervision by trained proctors during online exams. They monitor test-takers through video, audio, and chat and can respond quickly to suspicious behavior, technical issues, or rule violations. This human context is especially valuable for high-stakes assessments, where pausing the test, issuing a warning, or offering live guidance may be necessary.

OctoProctor’s live proctoring runs entirely in the browser and requires no downloads, integrates seamlessly with learning management systems, and allows proctors to monitor dozens of candidates at once. They can communicate directly with test takers via chat or audio, while identity verification is handled automatically before the exam begins. After each session, proctors can also review session recordings when needed.

By offering careful and non-intrusive monitoring, including mobile camera support and screen protection settings, live proctoring supports a secure testing environment while respecting candidate privacy.

Hybrid proctoring: how can AI and live proctoring come together?

Hybrid online proctoring combines automated cheating detection with human judgment to create a fairer and more efficient testing experience. AI can detect anomalies that may indicate misconduct, but technology alone can mistake normal actions (such as glancing away or background noise) for cheating or overlook subtle violations. Human expertise is essential here, as proctors provide perspective, critical thinking, and timely intervention to assess unusual situations accurately.

Relying only on live proctoring presents challenges as well. Monitoring large testing groups can divide a proctor’s attention and delay responses to risky situations. With AI support, proctors can focus on the issues that truly need expert attention.

Together, live + AI proctoring enable continuous integrity monitoring, fairness, and accuracy. AI-assisted exam supervision handles most of the routine checks, while record-and-review proctoring ensures that only flagged sessions require human evaluation, keeping costs manageable and operations efficient.

Our hybrid proctoring system allows exam administrators to create session templates, adjust alert settings, and decide which issues need to be addressed right away or reviewed after the exam. It includes features such as multiple camera angles, manual face checks, and live chat to strengthen security while supporting candidates. The system also tracks focus shifts, extra or unidentified faces, low microphone input, connectivity issues, and other potential signals of suspicious behavior.

By letting AI manage routine monitoring, human proctors can prioritize real concerns, such as technical support or accessibility accommodations. Hybrid proctoring also works with flexible scheduling and asynchronous exam monitoring, making it possible to conduct remote exams across different time zones.

Benefits of hybrid proctoring

AI and human proctoring together create a strong solution for online assessments. This combination offers a unique blend of efficiency, reliability, and trust. Here is how this model supports both institutions and test-takers.

1. Improved accuracy and detection

AI systems are excellent at spotting patterns and unusual behavior in large datasets, but they do not always capture the full picture. Human oversight makes a big difference, as people bring the experience and judgment needed to evaluate flagged activities properly. Together, AI and human proctors help institutions reduce false alarms and ensure that real misconduct is addressed quickly and more effectively.

2. Cost-effectiveness at scale

Using AI for assessment monitoring makes cost-effective proctoring possible, especially for large-scale exams. One-on-one human supervision is no longer required, which is a major advantage for organizations running online university exams, certification testing, or corporate training exams.

With hybrid proctoring, it becomes easier to scale securely while keeping exam integrity intact.

3. Real-time intervention for critical issues

One of the biggest benefits of the blended proctoring model is the ability to act immediately when issues occur. If AI misinterprets normal behavior as cheating, human intervention provides the necessary context. Exam supervisors can quickly review flagged activity through the proctoring dashboard and reach out with support or a warning when appropriate.

4. Scalability

A hybrid proctoring system is ideal for scalability, particularly for large organizations or testing environments that require flexibility. AI handles most of the monitoring, so human invigilators can focus on flagged issues or exams that need extra attention. This setup offers the best of both worlds: efficiency and integrity, without compromising either as you scale up.

5. Greater trust and fairness

Live + AI proctoring makes the exam process clearer and easier to follow. Test-takers can trust that everyone is being treated fairly, while administrators can rely on consistent and transparent results. By combining automated oversight with human review, this model strengthens confidence in the system and helps ensure that outcomes are credible for all participants.

When to choose hybrid proctoring

Choosing the right proctoring approach can be daunting, but hybrid proctoring offers a flexible solution that ensures fairness, integrity, and peace of mind for both candidates and administrators. Here are the key scenarios where it proves practical, secure, and adaptable:

License exams

Hybrid proctoring is an ideal solution for high-stakes exams such as the bar exam, driving tests, or drone certifications where live monitoring becomes challenging due to the large number of candidates. Combining AI and human review effectively addresses this issue. AI raises alerts for questionable actions, which are then escalated to human proctors. This approach helps ensure fairness while reducing the need for costly full live supervision.  

University programs with large cohorts

Managing exams for large student groups can be tricky, from scheduling to ongoing monitoring. Using both AI and human proctors makes the process more efficient and easier to manage.

For large-scale university exams, hybrid proctoring reduces the demand for real-time human supervision. Instead of monitoring every student live, automated exam monitoring handles most of the routine oversight, making it simpler to support large cohorts.

For low- to medium-stakes assessments such as midterms, practice tests, or quizzes, this blended model maintains academic integrity without requiring constant live proctoring. It also cuts down on administrative work, saving time for both instructors and students.

Asynchronous or global cohorts

Hybrid online proctoring is ideal for students taking exams across different time zones, as it allows them to complete assessments on their own schedule. This approach also supports students with limited or unstable internet connections. Sessions can be recorded locally and uploaded afterward, reducing stress while maintaining exam integrity.

Professional certifications

Hybrid proctoring works particularly well for professional certification exams, where maintaining test security is essential but full live supervision is not always required. For continuing education or compliance tests, it provides a reliable way to verify candidates’ performance while reducing administrative workload.

For vendor or partner certification exams, live + AI proctoring enables organizations to run tests worldwide without the hassle of scheduling a live proctor for every participant. Recruitment and pre-employment testing benefit from this approach, too. Companies can focus only on the sessions flagged by AI, making hiring faster while keeping it fair.

For internal upskilling programs, hybrid proctoring makes employee training and compliance assessments both reliable and cost-effective, while continuing to respect privacy.

Conclusion

Hybrid proctoring brings together AI automation and human oversight to create secure, fair, and scalable online assessments. AI handles routine monitoring and flags potential issues, while trained reviewers focus on the moments that require human judgment to ensure exam rules are applied consistently and respectfully.

At OctoProctor, we design hybrid proctoring systems that protect exam integrity, support learners across different locations and time zones, and reduce operational pressure on administrators. We believe this balanced model is the future of reliable remote exam delivery, prioritizing trust, accessibility, and a better experience for everyone involved. 🐙

Built for fairness, powered by balance

Hybrid proctoring isn't about replacing people with machines. It's about making exams smarter, fairer, and more human. At OctoProctor, we combine the precision of AI with the empathy of human judgment to protect academic integrity without compromising trust or privacy.

Have questions about how hybrid proctoring can work for your institution?

Get in touch.

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)

What is hybrid proctoring?

Hybrid proctoring uses both AI and human review to keep online exams secure and fair. The AI automatically detects potential issues, while live proctors step in to verify or act if something seems off. This balance improves accuracy, reduces bias, and keeps large-scale assessments efficient.

How does the blended proctoring model improve exam integrity?

AI monitors for irregularities such as extra faces, changes in focus, or unusual background noise. Human proctors then review these alerts to confirm whether they indicate real issues. This dual layer of review avoids false positives, prevents overlooked cheating, and keeps things fair for test takers.

Is hybrid online proctoring suitable for large-scale exams?

Yes. The system can handle thousands of exams at once. AI monitors all sessions, while human proctors only review cases that are flagged for further inspection. This approach allows institutions to scale securely and cost-effectively without sacrificing exam integrity.

How does OctoProctor protect privacy?

OctoProctor runs entirely in the browser and complies with international privacy standards such as GDPR and FERPA. It collects only essential data and encrypts all candidate information to ensure complete security and confidentiality.

What makes OctoProctor’s hybrid system unique?

Our hybrid system is flexible and easy to customize. It delivers real-time alerts, supports both live and record-and-review monitoring, and integrates smoothly with learning management systems. Together, these features help educators and organizations deliver secure, scalable, and accessible exams with less manual oversight.

Related posts

Let’s explore how sustainable online exams and responsible proctoring technology can support both educational fairness and the planet. From cloud-based infrastructure to low-impact operations, OctoProctor is paving the way for a greener EdTech future.

Meet release 5.6.0: lighter pages, resilient streams, and real-time search that thinks like you do. Test takers get guided chatbot-like checks; proctors get focused updates; Native speed, fewer tickets, cleaner UI – proctoring that scales without the stress.