A student on r/SNHU described an awkward situation. Their next assignment required them to use their instructor’s feedback that had not arrived. They were holding a draft, waiting for the information they needed to finish it. And, it’s far from being the first time. Alas, back-to-back assignments that rely on continuous feedback are another genre of evil.

Yup, educators can put a great deal of thought into an assessment, design it so one project succeeds the another, and still leave someone refreshing a page, wondering how they are supposed to do what we asked.
Whenever I dig past the tip of another education iceberg (I’m talking about you, Is this assessment comprehensive yet?), I always find at least 3 drastically different POVs from learners, educators, and academia. And sometimes parents and employers contribute their 5 cents. People like to disagree, but I think it’s important to hear each other at least when it comes to something as fundamental as education.
So, I decided to do what a communications specialist should know best – listen to all the main sides of the assessment story. 5 cents are cool, but in this economy I need at least a dollar to make the article work for everyone.
Formative assessment uses evidence of learning to guide the next step. A teacher spots a misconception and revisits it. A student reads comments on a draft and changes their argument. The useful bit happens when someone acts on what the assessment reveals.
For the student waiting on feedback, the opportunity to act was getting squeezed by the next deadline. I’d have trouble getting excited about the learning potential of that arrangement, too.
In a r/Teachers discussion, a second-year teacher asked whether formative work should be graded for accuracy, completion, or both. Replies pulled in different directions: keep completion checks manageable, allow reassessment after mistakes, or focus on competencies. It’s a deceptively difficult question. Award points for completion and the mark says little about understanding. Grade every early mistake and practice starts carrying the weight of a verdict. Meanwhile, someone has to read all this work. The queue is often quite human, so students may find it confusing and even annoying when it's the end of week 4, an assignment is due and needs week’s 3 feedback, yet the lecturer is still grading week 2 forum discussions.
The science gives formative assessment a qualified vote of confidence. Sortwell et al found learning effects ranging from trivial to large and positive in K–12 settings. Most of the evidence was rated low or very low in certainty, leaving limited grounds for declaring one strategy the winner.
I take that as a reason to look closely at the design. A two-minute free-form explanation can tell a teacher what to revisit tomorrow and may be less stressful than another essay disguised as a forum post. A carefully (and respectfully, please) annotated essay can help a student revise, provided revision is still possible. In any assessment method case, its usefulness depends on what happens afterward. If giving weekly feedback on a 2-page assignment for three 20-50 student classes is impossible, admins shouldn’t push impossible missions onto teaching staff either.

Before adding another formative task, I’d at least put the feedback date beside the next submission date.
Would students prefer a project to an exam? The answer gets interesting as soon as you ask more than one student. Some of us can’t stand group projects (the amount of memes about this predicament should speak for itself, really), some sink alone, and others are just panickingly afraid of another black box exam.
Let me support my frustrations practically. A University of Guelph student described being able to work on projects for hours while quickly losing energy when studying for tests. Some replies appreciated applying knowledge. Others preferred tests and quizzes because projects demanded more time and effort.
There is something appealing about a task with a definite ending, huh? Summative assessment judges achievement at a defined point and often contributes to a grade, qualification, or progression decision. An exam, performance, portfolio, or final project can all do that job.
Educators have to make that format workable. A LinkedIn exchange explored interactive oral assessment as a complement to written work, with counterarguments pointing out that oral assessments are not always feasible. So, in theory, distance learning students can be asked to record Looms discussing the covered materials, but there’s no dialogue value in that.
At a UK institution using concentrated teaching blocks with blended delivery, students and faculty perceived several smaller assessments as more accurate representations of learning than a single assessment at the end. Their responses also raised concerns about workload and timely feedback. These perceptions come from one setting, so they don't establish a universal advantage for more assignments. But as a student myself, I can definitely say that a 10-minute test here and there is less traumatic than a single 3-hour marathon through 12 weeks of material. And will that one final push tell the educators everything they need to conclude student’s knowledge? The responsibility of placing a grade that can affect quite a lot should not be taken carelessly – students should have chances to prove and correct themselves.
The first test can create anxiety before a course has properly begun. In r/AskTeachers, a parent asked how to prepare a nervous first grader for a diagnostic test. Respondents explained that the point was to find out what the child already knew. Studying for it was unnecessary. Do you think a 17-year-old starting a bachelor’s degree or even a 30-year-old applying for a new job would be any less nervous?

The Reddit post captures a communication problem. Tell someone they have a test, and they may reasonably assume they should try to ace it.
Diagnostic assessment identifies existing knowledge, strengths, and difficulties so teaching can respond. It often happens before instruction, although an educator can investigate a difficulty later, too. A short writing sample, conversation, or targeted quiz can help establish where to begin. I wouldn’t put a first grader under proctoring. I probably wouldn’t put a 17-year-old under proctoring to test whether they know something about a sociology 101 either. I would absolutely make a coding prospect pass a proctored test before moving with hiring, though. At least proves they exist and can do their work in accordance with the workplace’s regulations.
The educator’s question needs to be specific. In a r/ELATeachers discussion, someone teaching American literature in a multilingual high school wanted a clearer picture of students’ English reading comprehension. They distrusted the existing test results and were designing their own assessment. The useful information, for them, concerned the reading their course would require. This story also points out that a diagnostic assessment needs a plan for what comes next. I’d want the learner to hear that plan beforehand. We are checking these skills; here is how we will use the results; here is the support that can follow. If a writing sample reveals trouble evaluating sources, the next step might be a lesson on evidence. Simply recording “weak analysis” leaves everyone with a label and very little to do with it.
The first three assessment types describe the job the evidence is doing: finding a starting point, guiding learning, or judging achievement. The next three concern what we compare that evidence with. One assignment can therefore carry several labels.
Criterion-referenced assessment compares work with defined criteria or standards. Which brings us to a word I’d happily retire from unexplained rubric descriptors: “excellent.” Excellent according to whom, and visible where? A student grieved that their professor shared rubrics only after grading. According to them, the professor worried that providing rubrics earlier would turn the assignment into a checklist. From the learner’s side, the arrangement felt like guessing what the professor wanted.
On the other side, an adjunct teaching roughly 100 students without a teaching assistant asked how much individual feedback to give alongside a scored rubric. Line-edit everything? Mark major problems? Where should the work stop? Assessment tools can organize judgment, but someone still has to exercise it.
The more mass the education becomes, the harder it will be to grade and provide quality education with timely and sufficient feedback. But a world without education is far scarier than one with some education. Hence, in my opinion, criteria deserve time in the conversation before submission. Show what a supported argument looks like. Compare it with one that makes a confident claim and supplies no evidence. Discuss why the difference matters. “Uses relevant evidence to support the main claim” gives a learner more to work with than a box marked “excellent.”
A final essay judged this way is thus both summative and criterion-referenced.
In a student on r/ucr asked how a grading curve would affect exam marks and the final course grade. One reply questioned whether knowing the answer would change how much effort they put in. The student pushed back: they were simply trying to understand how the grading worked.
Asking how a judgment is made is a reasonable question, at least to me.
Norm-referenced assessment interprets performance relative to a defined group. A percentile rank tells you about your standing in that group. An 80th-percentile result does not mean you answered 80 percent of the questions correctly. It also cannot establish, by itself, whether you meet a particular standard of competence.
As a competitive overachiever student, I hate it. Tell me what I did best so I know why I am best in the class. I don't care about others’ results. And their results shouldn't influence mine, and mine should not touch on theirs.
Educators use “curving” to mean different things. Adding points, changing grade cutoffs, adjusting for problematic questions, and avoiding curves altogether. Some of those changes address flaws in an exam. Adding points to everyone does not automatically make a result norm-referenced; the defining feature is still comparison with other people’s performance.
Of course, that comparison can affect how feedback lands. Joshua Weidlich et al’ 2024 study involved 282 teacher-education students receiving automated feedback on an online collaborative task. Students receiving peer comparisons alone reported lower intrinsic motivation than those receiving minimal feedback. Combining comparisons with criteria did not show that decline. The study concerned formative feedback, which usefully reminds us that norm-referencing can appear during learning as well as in final grades.
Relative standing is useful information when ranking is the question. Undeniably helpful for performance-based scholarships. But for a learner trying to improve, I’d also want an explanation of what the work needs.
“I felt more confident in my writing, but I was also worried about my final score.”
That was one participant’s response in a 2024 study by Ebrahimi and Ebadi. It captures a tension I find particularly personal: recognizing your own improvement while wondering whether the grading system will recognize it, too.
Ipsative assessment compares your current performance with your own earlier performance. The reference point is your previous work. A teacher might compare two essays for changes in how you develop an argument, or two demonstrations for improvements in a practical skill.
Ebrahimi and Ebadi studied ten teenage English learners at an Iranian language institute. A teacher used screen recordings to compare drafts and explain progress. Their qualitative analysis described students engaging with earlier work, recognizing development, and feeling safer making mistakes. Some remained focused on scores. The small, specific study gives us a close look at that experience; broader claims about effectiveness need more evidence.
For educators, tracking progress raises a practical question: what should we keep? A LinkedIn discussion questioned permanently storing every draft and early misunderstanding. Or, perhaps retaining formative evidence to show growth over time. We need enough history to see development, and a reason for preserving it.
A portfolio with selected earlier and later work could make that comparison visible. The tasks need sufficiently similar demands, and the feedback needs to identify what changed. Two unrelated percentages will tell a much thinner story.
I also think learners deserve a clear distinction between progress and qualification. Someone can improve considerably and still need practice to meet a required standard. We can acknowledge that progress while explaining the remaining gap. Ipsative and criterion-referenced judgments can sit alongside each other without pretending to answer the same question.
What will this assessment let someone do next?
That is the question I’d ask before choosing assessment methods. The answer might be to revise an argument, change a lesson, demonstrate readiness, understand a ranking, or see progress that was previously hard to recognize.
Seen this way, educational assessment stops feeling administrative. The timing of feedback, the words in a rubric, and the group used for comparison shape what the result means to the person receiving it. They deserve as much attention as the task itself.
I keep thinking about that student waiting for feedback. Whatever we call the task, the calendar still has to leave them a chance to use it.
OctoProctor supports identity verification, exam monitoring, and records for review. Talk to our team about a setup that fits your assessment requirements and gives test takers clear expectations before the session begins.
Talk to us!Six commonly discussed types of educational assessment are diagnostic, formative, summative, criterion-referenced, norm-referenced, and ipsative. The first three describe purposes. The other three describe the basis for interpreting performance. Several labels can apply to one task.
A quiz can serve either purpose, or both. Using responses to guide practice gives it a formative role. Using the results to judge achievement gives it a summative role. Its length and online or paper format do not decide the distinction.
They can, depending on their design. Multiple-choice items can test interpretation as well as recall. A presentation can reveal reasoning and communication, provided the criteria address those skills. Choosing among types of tests in education requires looking at the actual questions and tasks.
Self-assessment identifies the learner as an assessor. Ipsative assessment identifies earlier personal performance as the comparison point. A learner can assess their own work against a rubric, and an educator can make an ipsative comparison between two pieces of that learner's work.
To explain the purposes of types of assessment used in education and training, connect each one to a decision. A diagnostic check helps identify training needs. Formative feedback guides practice. A summative judgment helps determine whether the required learning has been achieved. The same distinctions apply across assessment types in teaching and workplace training.
There is no universal quota. Choose assessments in education by the learning outcomes, the decisions required, and the opportunities to respond. Several tasks that repeat the same evidence can add workload. A smaller, carefully designed set may answer the questions the course needs to resolve.